This article is enhanced by Local Insights Pro.
Austin’s City Auditor will brief the City Council’s Audit and Finance Committee on Wednesday on which police, fire and EMS jobs could go to civilians instead of sworn staff.
The stakes are vacancies and overtime. As of September, Austin Police had 350 sworn vacancies, Austin-Travis County EMS 134 and Austin Fire 80, according to the auditor’s draft Civilian Staffing audit. The three departments reported overtime of $36.3 million, $18.1 million and $21 million in fiscal 2026, more than $75 million combined. The briefing is Item 6 on the committee’s Nov. 18 agenda, at 9:30 a.m. at City Hall, 301 W. Second St.
The departments employ more than 3,800 sworn staff and more than 700 civilians, the report says. A sworn employee’s annual salary runs about $19,000 more than a civilian’s. Between the 2019 and 2026 budgets, Fire and EMS added both sworn and civilian positions; Police lost both, especially civilian ones, which the auditors say has pushed more support work onto sworn officers.
The short version. The audit finds real desk work that civilians could take over now, but it says the immediate savings are limited. The bigger changes run through state civil service law and union contracts. The EMS contract expires Sept. 30, 2027, and Fire’s negotiations are not expected to resume until fiscal 2030, according to the departments’ own responses.
On the record. The auditors put the case this way: “every sworn staff member that can be moved from a non-operational role back to an operational role can help reduce costs.” The departments agreed to all four recommendations in a joint Nov. 10 management response, printed with the audit and signed by EMS Chief Robert Luckritz, Interim Fire Chief Tom Vocke, Police Chief Lisa Davis and Chief Labor Relations Officer Roxana Stevens. But the police section says city attorneys advised that “significant legal obstacles stand in the way of civilianizing positions within APD.” The fire section says, “Fire management has no intention of circumventing these legal requirements.”
The contracts are the real lever. Austin has adopted Chapter 143 of the Texas Local Government Code, the state civil service law for police, fire and EMS. Each department also has a labor agreement that can override parts of it: meet-and-confer agreements for Police and EMS, and a collective bargaining agreement for Fire. The auditors found no clear task at Austin Fire that a civilian could take over today without changing the fire contract.
Under the current agreements, the report says, emergency communications at EMS and Fire, fire training and some fire inspections stay sworn jobs. The auditors point to El Paso, where 144 dispatch positions include one sworn role, a battalion chief who supervises call-takers. El Paso does not follow Chapter 143, the report notes, so the comparison has limits.
What civilians could do now. The report lists tasks staff and consultants identified:
- EMS: Sworn employees have spent hours answering public information requests. Civilians could also move vehicles between stations, schedule maintenance, run injury prevention outreach and help trainers with scheduling and equipment.
- Police: Civilians could handle recruiting outreach and background checks, IT support, daily care of mounted patrol horses, wrecker enforcement and running the firing range at the training academy, which sworn officers now manage on top of other duties.
- Fire: With contract changes, civilians could help with training, fleet repair, building-system inspections and dispatch.
Austin Police hired a consultant in 2024, BerryDunn, to look at the same question. The department moved some sworn staff to patrol afterward, but leadership told auditors it has not carried out some of the consultant’s recommendations on using more civilians.
What the documents don’t say. The audit’s summary says civilianizing jobs can cut costs, but it does not put a dollar figure on the savings. Instead, it asks each chief to estimate the savings, including reduced overtime, as part of a plan. No department response in the report includes an estimate.
The timelines are also slower than “agree” suggests. EMS and Fire say they will list possible civilian tasks by Feb. 1 each year during budget development, then decide by March 1 whether to request civilian positions for the next budget year or two years out. Police says it will fold the same questions into its annual budget review. All three list the implementation date as annually on Oct. 1, with the work final only upon renewal of the next labor agreement.
The report and the police response also read the legal picture differently. The auditors wrote that Austin Police does not face Chapter 143 or contract limits on civilians as specific as Fire’s and EMS’s. The police response cites a 1991 Texas Supreme Court ruling, Lee v. City of Houston, which held that jobs requiring knowledge of police work must be classified as sworn, and says the fuller legal analysis sits in a privileged memo from the City Attorney’s Office.
What’s unresolved. How much Austin could save by moving desk work to civilians is the open question, and the departments’ plans are supposed to answer it. Which police jobs city attorneys consider off-limits is in a memo the public can’t see. The Dispatch has not yet put either question to the departments; the committee can ask Wednesday.
What happens next. The Audit and Finance Committee meets at 9:30 a.m. Wednesday, Nov. 18, at City Hall, 301 W. Second St.; some members may join by video. Mayor chairs it, with Council Member as vice chair and Council Members , José “Chito” Vela and Marc Duchen.
Briefings are not open for public sign-up, according to the agenda, but up to five speakers can address topics not on the agenda for three minutes each. Instructions are on the city’s Council Committee Information Center, and the meeting streams on ATXN. The EMS labor agreement expires Sept. 30, 2027.
