Austin City Council will vote Nov. 19 on an ordinance that would bar nonprofits competing for city social services money from lobbying City Hall while bids are open.
The city spent about $100 million with 95 nonprofit organizations for family and social services in fiscal 2025, according to a July 2026 City Auditor’s report. Those contracts pay for things like mental health care, permanent supportive housing and homelessness services. Under Austin’s anti-lobbying ordinance, they are the first item on the list of exceptions, so nonprofits seeking the money can talk to council members and staff while a solicitation is open. Bidders in most other city solicitations that need council approval cannot.
Two items on the Nov. 19 draft agenda would change that. Item 71, a draft ordinance, strikes social services from the exceptions list. Item 70, a resolution, directs the city manager to put social services contracts and grants under the city’s standard procurement and grant rules. Mayor Kirk Watson sponsors both, with Mayor Pro Tem José “Chito” Vela and Council Members Ryan Alter and Vanessa Fuentes as co-sponsors.
The short version: The auditor first raised the lobbying exemption in 2019, and the city never acted on it. The new ordinance would finally close it. But the draft also rewrites the rules for every city solicitation covered by the ordinance, shortening the no-lobbying window at both ends and moving appeals away from the Ethics Review Commission. Neither of those changes is in the agenda summary’s headline.
What the audit found. Auditors sampled 25 nonprofit contracts worth about $30 million. In 19 of them, or 76%, the nonprofit missed at least one performance expectation, and across all 151 expectations reviewed, 67, or 44%, were not met. For more than half of the missed expectations, what was delivered was more than 40% below the target. The city mostly pays these contracts on a cost-reimbursement basis, meaning nonprofits are generally paid for expenses “regardless of outcomes,” the report says.
City management agreed. In a July 14 response signed by City Manager T.C. Broadnax and included in the report, management wrote: “The City of Austin’s current policy prevents award of these taxpayer dollars in accordance with procurement industry standards.” The same response said six of seven peer cities surveyed in 2019 apply anti-lobbying rules to social services procurement, and recommended applying a competitive bid requirement and the anti-lobbying ordinance “to all solicitations and awards of taxpayer dollars,” with a proposed implementation date of Oct. 1, 2027.
Watson pushed the change at the council’s Audit and Finance Committee on Oct. 21. According to the city’s closed-caption transcript of that meeting, he said the city spends more than $100 million on nonprofit contracts without the anti-lobbying rule and ought to apply it. The Dispatch covered that meeting and the broader social services rewrite at the time.
The window gets shorter for everyone. Austin’s code defines a “no-lobbying period” during which bidders and their agents cannot lobby council members or city staff about a solicitation. Under the current definition, that period starts when a solicitation is published. It runs until the earliest of three dates: the last contract is signed, 60 days after council authorizes the last contract, or the city cancels the solicitation.
The draft ordinance would start the clock when responses are due instead of when the solicitation is published. It would end the period on the day council authorizes or declines the last contract, or on cancellation, and drop the contract-signing and 60-day options. That means the period would no longer cover the time between when a city request for proposals goes out and when bids come in. Because the definition applies to every solicitation the ordinance covers, the change would reach other city purchases, not just nonprofit social services funding.
Appeals move to the purchasing office. Today, a bidder disqualified for violating the ordinance can appeal to a subcommittee of the Ethics Review Commission, a volunteer citizen board, whose decision is final. The draft strikes that language and sends appeals through the city’s standard protest procedures for solicitations instead. The draft does not describe what those procedures are or who hears them.
A new safe harbor for nonprofits. The draft adds a permitted communication: talks between a bidder and a city official or employee “on matters generally related to social services and the communities served and matters outside the scope of an active solicitation.” It keeps other exceptions in place, including city cultural arts funding and federal, state or city block grant funding.
The document against the announcement. The agenda’s posting language says the ordinance would “adjust the no-lobbying period” and “clarify the appeal process.” The draft itself shows the adjustment is a narrowing at both ends, and the clarification removes the Ethics Review Commission from appeals. The recommendation for action posted with the item includes no explanation, background or fiscal note. The draft also leaves its effective date blank and labels two different sections “Part 3.”
The resolution leans heavily on the audit. It lists management’s planned fixes, including extending the city’s contractor performance evaluation program beyond the Capital Procurement Division to all city contracts and moving compliance for department-managed contracts into Austin Financial Services. It also asks the city manager to name staff who can help social services providers with applications and bidding, and to post their contact information on the city website.
What’s unresolved. The backup posted Nov. 6 does not say why the sponsors want a shorter no-lobbying period for all city bids, or why disqualification appeals should leave the Ethics Review Commission. It also does not say when the new rules would first apply to a social services solicitation. The mayor’s office and the city’s purchasing office could answer those questions.
What happens next. Council convenes Thursday, Nov. 19, at 10 a.m. at Austin City Hall, 301 W. Second St. The posted agenda is a draft, and items can change before the final version. Speaker sign-up and viewing information is on the city’s Nov. 19 meeting page. If approved, the city manager’s office would then rewrite the procurement manual and grant procedures, with the audit’s management response targeting full implementation by Oct. 1, 2027.
