Austin’s City Auditor will present a draft audit of city employee credit cards to the City Council’s Audit and Finance Committee on Wednesday.
City staff spent almost $45 million on 1,571 individually assigned cards in fiscal 2025, not counting Austin Energy, according to the draft Credit Cards audit. At least 27% of those cards, 419, were used less than once a month. In a sample of 120 purchases, 35% had no clear business reason. The briefing is Item 5 on the committee’s Nov. 18 agenda.
Austin is an outlier among big Texas cities, the auditors found. It has more cards than Houston (867), Dallas (475), El Paso (449), Fort Worth (436) or San Antonio (370), about 10 city staff per card, compared with about 37 in San Antonio. Austin also spent about $28,400 per card, roughly $5,000 more than the next city that reported its spending.
The report lands two weeks after Austin voters rejected Proposition I, a citizen-initiated charter amendment that would have required regular independent efficiency reviews, in unofficial results from the Nov. 3 election. The card audit comes from the city’s own auditor, an office created by the City Charter that reports to the council; it was on the office’s 2026 audit plan.
On the record. The auditors’ summary is blunt: “These conditions increase the risk of fraud, misuse, and unnecessary spending.” Austin Financial Services, which runs the card program, agreed to all four recommendations. Its response also says, “Departments will remain responsible for determining the appropriateness of purchases within their operational authority.”
The receipts don’t say much. The auditors sampled 120 purchases from four departments: Facilities Management, Parks and Recreation, Public Health and Austin Water. About a fifth, 25, did not clearly say what was bought, and 38 only partly matched or did not match the receipt. The sample was not designed to be statistically significant, the report notes, so the rates can’t be projected citywide.
- Vague descriptions: “PDC Coffee Supplies,” $1,521; “automatic toll charge,” $1,050; “out on leave,” $285; “video,” $168.
- Miscoded buys: A step stool, a medical journal subscription and “Chat GPT” were each filed under “clothing/clothing material.”
- Generic categories: $4.2 million was coded to “small tools/minor equipment” and $2.8 million to “services-other.”
One real check, sometimes none. Purchases are supposed to be reviewed by the cardholder’s supervisor and then a department accountant. One accountant approved as many as 7,381 transactions in fiscal 2025, and the average was 1,253. Another 4,541 purchases were auto-approved, skipping the supervisor entirely. Accountants told auditors they check that paperwork exists, not whether a purchase was clear or necessary.
Nobody looks at the whole bill. The auditors found no one in city government responsible for reviewing overall card spending. Card spending on tolls was about $863,000, with about $560,000 from two departments, neither of which had studied whether paying tolls was cost-effective. The report does not name those departments.
Training is one-time and focuses on the software, and 37% of the 769 card users who answered a survey said they did not remember it or did not find it helpful.
This is not hypothetical, the report says. Investigations by the City Auditor’s Integrity Unit since 2020 found employees using city cards for personal purchases, including one case of at least $1.3 million in goods.
The $45 million is not the whole bill. The audit’s headline figure covers only cards assigned to employees by name. Its footnotes add two more groups: 137 contract and “scoped” cards tied to a vendor or purchase category, which carried about $32 million, and Austin Energy’s 237 employee cards, which carried about $10 million by the utility’s own count.
Added together, that is roughly $87 million on about 1,945 city cards in fiscal 2025. Treat it as an approximation, since the report says some contract purchases may sit inside the $45 million.
The city does earn something back. Staff reported about $1.2 million in card rebates in fiscal 2025, the report says, though auditors wrote that the benefits of heavy card use “may be offset by fraud, misuse, or unnecessary spending.”
The transparency promise. In a June 12 memo to the mayor and council, Austin Financial Services Director Kim Olivares and Budget and Organizational Excellence Director Kerri Lang said all ProCard transactions were expected to become public on the city’s data portal beginning with the 2026-27 budget year, which started Oct. 1. The audit says the city plans to post the data later this year. The Dispatch has not confirmed whether that dataset is live.
What’s unresolved. The audit does not estimate how much of the $45 million was unnecessary, and it does not name the two departments behind most of the toll spending. Financial Services could answer both; the Dispatch has not yet asked. Every fix in the management response carries the same implementation date, October 2027, nearly a year from now.
What happens next. The committee meets at 9:30 a.m. Wednesday, Nov. 18, at City Hall, 301 W. Second St. Briefings are not open for public sign-up, according to the agenda; up to five speakers may address other topics for three minutes each, with instructions on the city’s Council Committee Information Center. The meeting streams on ATXN. Financial Services has promised an annual card review, yearly refresher training, two levels of review on every purchase and an annual spending analysis by October 2027.
