Austin FC has finally said something. What it said is a little harder to pin down.
In a three-paragraph message posted Friday, Oct. 16, along with a Spanish-language version, the club said it and the leaders of supporters’ groups Austin Anthem, Los Verdes and La Murga de Austin “recently held a series of discussions focused on our shared priority of protecting vulnerable members of our Hispanic and immigrant communities.”
“We empathize with the anxiety many in the Austin FC family are feeling right now, and we continue to stand firmly with you,” the statement says. It adds that “several actions are already underway” as a result of those talks.
It doesn’t say what those actions are. The statement also doesn’t mention U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement, the fan who was removed from Q2 Stadium for wearing an anti-ICE shirt, or whether the stadium rule used to remove her will change.
How we got here. On Sept. 26, Austin FC’s Hispanic Heritage Night against San Diego FC, Q2 Stadium staff removed Daniela Silva from the grounds after she refused to cover a shirt that read “ABOLISH ICE.” According to the Austin Chronicle, she turned down requests from club staff, then stadium security, then an Austin police officer, and was given a 12-month ban. The Chronicle identified Silva as an Austin policy coordinator who narrowly lost the 2022 District 3 City Council race.
That match came six days after an ICE officer shot Wilber Rafael Garces Perez, a Venezuelan asylum seeker, in North Austin on Sept. 20. The Travis County District Attorney’s Office released a statement the same day.
In an emailed statement to the Chronicle, the club said Silva’s shirt broke a Q2 Stadium policy against “signs, symbols, or images displayed for commercial purposes for electioneering, campaigning or advocating for or against any candidate, political party, legislative issues or government action.” The club also told the Chronicle that ICE “has not been present at Q2 Stadium during matches” and “does not use Austin FC’s offices or facilities.”
The stadium rule matches the text of Major League Soccer’s fan code of conduct. An MLS spokesperson, however, told The Guardian that the league’s policy doesn’t govern clothing, and that a stadium’s policy would.
The ban, two ways. According to the Guardian, Austin FC said the ban was issued by the Austin Police Department, not the club, and that it offered to rescind the ban but Silva declined. Austin FC officials told the Austin American-Statesman on Friday that they had contacted Silva and offered to lift the stadium ban. They also told the Statesman that APD still has a 12-month criminal trespass notice active against her. If that police notice stands, lifting the stadium ban alone wouldn’t appear to let her back in.
The supporters push back. In an Oct. 5 joint statement posted by Los Verdes, Los Verdes and La Murga de Austin called the removal unacceptable. “Our Hispanic and immigrant communities are not a theme, a marketing campaign, or something to celebrate only when it is easy,” the groups wrote. They asked the club to review how it enforces its security, law enforcement and fan conduct policies, and asked MLS to revise its code so that rules meant to limit political campaigning aren’t used “to silence supporters speaking out about the safety, dignity, and rights of their communities.” Austin Anthem issued a separate statement with much of the same language.
Then the music stopped. At the Saturday, Oct. 10 home match against Nashville SC, during ACL Fest weekend two, La Murga finished its usual “Bella Ciao” in the ninth minute, unfurled a banner reading “NO ICE IN THIS MELTING POT,” and walked out of the south stand along with some members of Los Verdes and Austin Anthem, the Chronicle reported. The Guardian reported that the banner was taken down. Austin FC lost 4-1, ending an eight-game unbeaten streak.
“We love this club. But love is not silent,” La Murga said in a statement quoted by the Chronicle. The band asked the club “to speak out – publicly, with conviction – against the injustice ICE is inflicting on the communities of Austin.”
What Friday’s statement does and doesn’t do. The club’s message is the first public sign that it has been meeting with the groups. That counts for something, and the club says the groups’ leaders were part of those talks. It is not the public stand against ICE that La Murga asked for, and it doesn’t say what happens the next time someone walks through the gates in Silva’s shirt. The Chronicle’s Verde Report column had already predicted the club was unlikely to issue an organization-wide condemnation of ICE, noting that MLS rules would likely discourage it.
Austin FC played its next home match Saturday, Oct. 17, losing 2-1 to Vancouver Whitecaps FC in front of 20,738 people, according to the club’s match report. The team’s next match is on the road at Sporting Kansas City on Oct. 24.
As of Monday morning, none of the three supporters’ groups had publicly accepted or rejected the club’s statement in anything we could find. If the “actions” include a change to how Q2 enforces its political-speech rule, the club hasn’t said so.
