Burnet and Webb petitions are in. Here’s the state calendar that now decides Austin ISD’s takeover risk

Petitions to close Burnet and Webb middle schools were due Oct. 15. The Oct. 30 enrollment snapshot, a Dec. 1 deadline and a Feb. 15 order come next.

Share this storyXFacebookLinkedIn

The William B. Travis State Office Building, a tall pale stone office tower with horizontal bands of dark windows under a blue sky, home to the Texas Education Agency in Austin.

Parent petitions asking the state to close Burnet and Webb middle schools were due to Austin ISD Superintendent Matias Segura by 11:59 p.m. Thursday, Oct. 15. That ended weeks of door-knocking and drop-off-line pitches over whether to close the two campuses or risk a state takeover of the whole district. The outcome is still unknown, and the deadlines that decide it run through mid-February.

The next date is Friday, Oct. 30, the statewide enrollment snapshot. That count decides which signatures are valid. Here is what the law requires, what is still unknown, and the calendar from here.

Why the petitions exist

Burnet and Webb have preliminary F ratings for a fifth straight year. Under Texas Education Code Section 39A.111, a campus with five consecutive unacceptable ratings triggers a mandatory order from the education commissioner, now Mike Morath. He must choose between two actions:

  • appointing a board of managers to govern the district, which replaces the elected trustees and brings a commissioner-appointed superintendent
  • closing the campus

The margins were narrow. Preliminary data gave Burnet an overall score of 59 and Webb 58, one and two points short of the 60 needed for a D, the Austin Current reported. AISD has appealed both ratings. In a Sept. 14 letter to families, Segura wrote that the ratings “will be finalized in December.”

Section 39A.112 lets parents weigh in. If the commissioner receives a petition signed by the parents of a majority of a campus’s students, requesting one of the two actions, the law says “the commissioner shall, except as otherwise authorized by this section, order the specific action requested.” Mayor Kirk Watson urged Burnet and Webb families in September to petition for closure, betting it would head off a districtwide takeover, according to the Austin Current.

Where the signatures stood

The Austin Council of PTAs led the signature drive. By Tuesday afternoon, Oct. 13, it had gathered 48% of the signatures needed at Burnet and 36% at Webb, KUT reported. By Thursday afternoon, council President Crystal Brothwell Hernandez put Burnet at roughly 300 parent signatures, enough for a majority. She estimated Webb was “just less than 20 to 30 short,” CBS Austin reported. A later Austin American-Statesman report, citing the PTA, said a majority of families had signed. AISD has not released any counts.

Signatures alone don’t make a petition valid. The district told CBS Austin in a written statement that “the petitions must be validated by the superintendent based on the campus enrollment on the state-wide enrollment snapshot date on Oct. 30.” It said it would begin once the snapshot is final and “submit the results to TEA by Dec. 1.”

What makes a signature count

The commissioner’s rule, 19 Texas Administrative Code Section 97.1065, sets these tests:

  • Who can sign. A parent counts only if listed on the student’s campus registration form, and only one signature per student counts.
  • Which students count. The student must be enrolled at the campus on the snapshot date. That means the math moves if students enroll or withdraw before Oct. 30.
  • How many. Parents of more than 50% of enrolled students must give a handwritten or typed name and an original signature.
  • When signed. A signature is valid only if made on or after the date of the preliminary rating showing four or more straight unacceptable years.

TEA’s model closure petition says plainly what parents are signing: “By signing this form, I want my student’s school to be closed at the end of the school year.” It also says, “To be considered a valid signature, a parent must complete all information below.”

That line matters because of how some forms reached families. Parents told CBS Austin that petitions came home already filled in with family information, needing only a date and signature. Brothwell Hernandez said those forms did not come from the district or the PTA council. Parents also raised a language barrier. TEA’s template is in English only, and more than 77% of students at both schools do not speak English at home, KUT reported. Neither the rule nor TEA’s form says whether a pre-filled form is invalid. Segura’s validation, due Dec. 1, is the first place that question would be answered.

A petition may not be the last word

Even a valid petition doesn’t bind the state completely.

  • Layered sanctions. The same rule says that alongside a closure or board-of-managers order, the commissioner may impose any other sanction under state law, “singly or in combination.” That specifically includes a monitor, conservator, management team or board of managers.
  • AISD’s own warning. Segura wrote families that the commissioner “ultimately has the ability to enact a range of interventions and/or layer interventions based on the district’s needs.”
  • No answer from TEA. TEA declined to tell the Austin Current how the petition provision interacts with that broader authority.
  • The trustees’ option. The elected board can ask the commissioner for the other action instead. Under the rule, that request needs a majority vote in a public meeting and a written explanation, submitted by Dec. 15. The commissioner “may” grant it.
  • Both schools are needed. The Austin Council of PTAs says on its state intervention page that if only one school’s petition succeeds, takeover risk remains.

The most recent precedent cuts both ways. In 2019, Snyder ISD parents petitioned to close Snyder Junior High. Morath ordered the closure but also appointed a conservator, the Austin Current reported.

If the schools close, what replaces them is limited

Watson’s proposal suggested AISD could turn the $158 million Burnet building now under construction into a school serving both communities, the Austin Current reported. State law constrains that. Under Section 39A.113, a campus closed by the commissioner can be reopened at the same site only if the commissioner finds it offers “a distinctly different academic program.” It must also either serve mostly grade levels the old school didn’t serve, or be run by a qualifying nonprofit operator with a strong ratings record. For the first route, most of its students can’t have attended the closed school the year before. The same section says students at a closed campus must be allowed to transfer to any district school serving their grade, with transportation on request.

The calendar from here

  • Oct. 30: statewide enrollment snapshot. It sets the count each petition must top.
  • Dec. 1: deadline for the superintendent to send any valid petition to the commissioner.
  • December: final 2025-26 ratings, including the outcome of AISD’s appeals. If an appeal lifts a school to a D, its five-year streak ends and so does its trigger.
  • Dec. 15: deadline for trustees to ask for a different action.
  • Jan. 30: if closure is requested, AISD must submit a comprehensive closure plan.
  • Feb. 15: deadline for the commissioner’s order. The rule says it applies for the current school year or, if necessary, the next one.

The district could challenge a closure or board-of-managers decision before the State Office of Administrative Hearings. Under Section 39A.301, that review is expedited and the judge’s decision is final.

The bigger picture

Even if Burnet and Webb close, the threat may return. TEA ruled that Paredes Middle School’s history of failing ratings transfers to Bailey Middle School, which took most of its students. It said the same applies to five other closing schools with four unacceptable ratings, the Austin Current reported via The Texas Tribune. That raised the number of AISD schools that could trigger intervention in 2026-27 from three to nine.

For Burnet and Webb families, the immediate question is simpler. Whether their signatures count will be settled by a headcount two weeks from now, not by the petition drive that ended Thursday night.

Featured image: The William B. Travis State Office Building at 1701 N. Congress Ave. in Austin, home to the Texas Education Agency’s headquarters. Photo by LoneStarMike, CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons.