, , ,

Two more city commissions ask Council to seek APD apology to Anthoneil Williams II’s family

The Commission on Immigrant Affairs and the African American Resource Advisory Commission asked Council to urge an APD apology to Anthoneil Williams II’s family and end use of ‘suicide by cop’ during investigations.

Share this storyXFacebookLinkedIn

First page of Commission on Immigrant Affairs Recommendation 20261005-006, Recognition of Recent APD Shooting and Supporting Measures to Provide Public Accountability

Two more of Austin’s advisory commissions have formally asked the City Council to press the police chief to apologize to the family of Anthoneil Williams II, the 17-year-old killed by Austin police officers in July, and to stop police and city officials from calling such deaths “suicide by cop” while investigations are still open. The recommendations are advice to Council, not policy, but they add to a growing list of city bodies on record about how the Austin Police Department talks about officer-involved shootings.

The votes. The Commission on Immigrant Affairs approved Recommendation 20261005-006 by an 8-0 vote on Oct. 5, according to the signed recommendation. The African American Resource Advisory Commission approved the same text as Recommendation 20261006-005 by an 11-0 vote on Oct. 6, according to its signed recommendation. No members voted against either one. Three Immigrant Affairs commissioners and four African American Resource Advisory commissioners were absent. The final documents are posted with the meeting records for Immigrant Affairs and the African American Resource Advisory Commission.

What the commissions are asking for. Both recommendations urge the Council to:

  • Condemn police misconduct, excessive force and “reckless tactical failures” that have caused deadly harm, and reaffirm the city’s commitment to accountability.
  • Call on the police chief to issue a formal public apology to Williams’ family for describing his death as “suicide by cop” or “suicide by police” while investigations were ongoing.
  • Ask the city manager to direct APD and other departments to stop using that kind of language as a premature or conclusory description of police-involved deaths, and to use “neutral, fact-based language” instead.
  • Call on officers, 911 call takers and other first responders to recognize signs of a suicidal or behavioral health crisis and to emphasize time, distance, de-escalation and crisis intervention, citing guidance from the Police Executive Research Forum.
  • Support the Community Police Review Commission’s efforts to obtain every piece of evidence and unredacted record in the Williams case.
  • Ask the city manager to propose a permanent memorial to people killed by police in Austin since 2000.

The shooting. Officers shot Williams early on July 24 at a community park in the 10100 block of Baden Lane in Northeast Austin after a 911 caller reported a young person with a gun, according to APD’s news release. Police said officers did not find a firearm, and that the 911 call came from Williams’ own phone. Police later determined he had a water bottle in his waistband, CNN reported. Three officers fired and were placed on administrative leave. APD and the Travis County District Attorney’s Office are conducting a criminal investigation, and APD Internal Affairs is conducting an administrative investigation with oversight from Austin Police Oversight, according to the department.

At a news conference the day of the shooting, Police Chief Lisa Davis said, “All points are indicating that this was a suicide by police,” while noting the investigation was active, CNN reported. The recommendations cite that statement. They also cite criticism of the label from the National Police Accountability Project and say such terms, used before an investigation establishes intent, risk “shifting responsibility for a police-involved death onto the deceased.” The Texas Observer has reported on how the term is defined and used.

APD’s account. In an update released July 29, APD said body-worn camera and surveillance footage showed Williams lift his shirt, reach toward his waistband, then raise both hands toward officers “as if he was pointing a weapon at the officers.” Police have said the 911 caller asked for police, not mental health services, and that the call was not identified as a mental health crisis, according to CNN. The department told KUT this month that it is working to strengthen training and communication for officers and 911 call takers on calls that may involve mental health emergencies.

Other bodies on record. The text of the two recommendations matches Recommendation 20260923-007, posted for the city’s Joint Inclusion Committee. The Mayor’s Committee for People with Disabilities voted 7-0 on Oct. 9 for a separate recommendation that asks the city to bar officials from using labels such as “suicide by cop” before investigations are complete; that document does not name Williams.

A second Immigrant Affairs vote. At the same Oct. 5 meeting, the Commission on Immigrant Affairs voted 7-0, with Commissioner De La Rosa abstaining, for a separate recommendation about the Sept. 20 shooting of Wilber Rafael Garces Perez by a U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement officer in North Austin. It asks the Council to connect his family with support services, ask federal authorities to ensure he gets medical care and is not deported before an independent investigation is complete, seek regular public updates on APD’s investigation, and send a letter to Texas’ congressional delegation. The document lists the abstention but does not give a reason.

What’s next. Commission recommendations go to the City Council as advice. As of Oct. 20, none of these recommendations appeared on the agenda for the Council’s Oct. 22 meeting, and no Council date for them has been posted.