Garza calls Abbott’s new ad on a 1991 Austin murder misleading. The court record is messier than either side’s version

Gov. Greg Abbott’s campaign has a new ad about the 1991 killing of Anita Byington. DA José Garza calls it misleading, but the court that threw out Allen Causey’s conviction didn’t find him innocent either.

Share this storyXFacebookLinkedIn

The Supreme Court Building in downtown Austin, which houses the Texas Supreme Court and the Texas Court of Criminal Appeals

A week before Election Day, the Texas governor’s race has landed on a 35-year-old Austin murder case. And the court record behind it doesn’t fit neatly into anybody’s 30-second spot.

On Monday, Oct. 26, Texans for Greg Abbott released a new ad featuring Kristina Byington. Her cousin, 21-year-old Anita Byington, was beaten to death in East Austin in August 1991. The campaign’s release describes Byington as a lifelong Democrat who blames Travis County District Attorney José Garza for failing to keep her cousin’s killer behind bars, and who now plans to vote for Abbott.

Garza fired back the same day. In a statement, his office called the ad misleading and said it accuses the DA of “releasing a confessed murderer.” Garza’s office says Allen Andre Causey, the man convicted of the killing, was wrongfully convicted. “Mr. Causey was wrongfully convicted of a crime he did not commit,” Garza said. “His conviction was overturned by the all-Republican Texas Court of Criminal Appeals.”

What the court actually said. Both sides are leaning on the same April 16, 2025, opinion from the Court of Criminal Appeals, the state’s top criminal court. The unsigned opinion threw out Causey’s 1992 murder conviction. It said the new evidence that had surfaced “includes DNA implicating an alternate suspect, testimony from witnesses contradicting parts of Causey’s confession, and allegations of police misconduct.”

The next line is the one neither side puts in bold: “Although this Court does not find that the evidence shows Applicant to be actually innocent, this Court finds that habeas relief should be granted based on the State’s unknowing use of false testimony.” The court sent the case back so Causey would face the original indictment again. Three of the court’s judges dissented in two opinions, and one didn’t participate. In one dissent, Judge Kevin Yeary noted that Garza’s office agreed Causey should get relief. Yeary argued the court should have heard oral arguments that included a lawyer for the victim’s family before ruling.

So Garza’s line that Causey was cleared of “a crime he did not commit” goes further than the court did. The ad’s framing has its own gaps, though.

The “release” part. Causey wasn’t freed by the DA. He left prison on parole in October 2022, after about three decades behind bars, according to FOX 7 Austin and the National Registry of Exonerations. That was before his lawyers with the Innocence Project of Texas filed for a new trial in 2023. In Texas, parole is decided by the Board of Pardons and Paroles, whose members are appointed by the governor.

What Garza did do came later. After the appeals court ruling, his office dismissed the case on May 20, 2025, according to the registry. FOX 7 reported that Causey then received more than $2.5 million in wrongful-imprisonment compensation from the state comptroller in July 2025. The Texan reported that Garza supported that compensation claim. It also reported that Texas pays $80,000 for each year of wrongful imprisonment, and that the law allows payment when a prosecutor finds no credible evidence to retry a case or believes a defendant is actually innocent, even without a court finding of innocence.

The confession. Causey’s 1991 confession was taken by Austin police officers who worked for Sgt. Hector Polanco, a homicide supervisor who, The Texan reported, was accused of using intimidation to extract false confessions. Polanco testified at the 1992 trial that he had never been alone with Causey. The trial judge who held the 2024 hearing found the new evidence pointed toward another man, Kevin Harris, but ruled that it “does not constitute affirmative evidence of applicant’s innocence.” Garza’s office says it is still seeking justice for Anita Byington and “will continue fighting to hold the actual perpetrator accountable.”

The family. Kristina Byington has been fighting the exoneration effort publicly for years. In a 2023 essay, she wrote that her family wasn’t told when the DA’s office and the Innocence Project began re-interviewing witnesses. She called the effort a “travesty” and a “sham.” Abbott’s campaign has featured her story since at least March, when it used the case to pitch his proposal for a statewide chief prosecutor who could take cases away from local DAs.

Garza isn’t on this year’s ballot. Abbott and Hinojosa are, and Election Day is Tuesday, Nov. 3. Travis County early voting runs through Friday, Oct. 30.