Feds haven’t fulfilled a single evidence request in Austin ICE shooting, Garza tells House Democrats

In an Oct. 14 letter to Rep. Bennie Thompson, Travis County District Attorney José Garza said federal agencies haven’t met any APD or DA requests for witnesses, video or records about the Sept. 20 ICE shooting of Wilber Rafael Garces Perez.

Share this storyXFacebookLinkedIn

Exterior of the Blackwell-Thurman Criminal Justice Center in downtown Austin

Nearly four weeks after a U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement officer shot a DoorDash driver in North Austin, local investigators say they’re still waiting on the federal government for the basics: witnesses, video and records.

Travis County District Attorney José Garza put that in writing in an Oct. 14 letter to Rep. Bennie Thompson, D-Miss., the ranking member of the U.S. House Committee on Homeland Security. His office posted the letter Oct. 15.

“As of this writing, the federal government has not fulfilled any of APD or TCDA’s requests to access evidence in this case,” Garza wrote.

What the letter says. Garza wrote that Austin Police Department Special Investigations Unit detectives and a representative from his office went to the scene on the afternoon of Sept. 20. APD opened a criminal investigation, which he said “remains active and ongoing and is supported by TCDA’s Civil Rights Unit.”

Since Sept. 21, Garza wrote, APD has made “multiple requests to federal law enforcement agencies for access to material evidence.” Those requests include interviews with key witnesses, video footage, records and other documents held by the federal government. His office has made similar requests separately.

He wrote that requests like these “are customary in any investigation where local and federal jurisdiction overlap and are usually accommodated by federal authorities.”

Garza declined to share any facts or preliminary findings because the investigation is pending. He did praise the police. His office is “deeply grateful for the leadership of Chief Lisa Davis,” he wrote, and APD’s work so far has been “diligent and thorough.”

About that “testimony.” The DA’s release bills the letter as testimony to the House Homeland Security Committee. It’s more accurately a written submission to a minority-party event. The committee’s Democrats announced an Oct. 15 “Democratic field hearing” in Austin, led by Rep. Greg Casar, D-Texas, with Thompson, Rep. Pramila Jayapal, D-Wash., and five other Democrats. FOX 7 Austin described it as a shadow hearing, the kind lawmakers hold when they don’t have the majority needed to call an official one. Republicans control the House and the committee.

At the hearing, FOX 7 reported, Thompson said federal agencies “are also refusing to provide any requested information on evidence to local police investigators.” Lauren Pena, Casar’s Republican opponent, said in a statement to the station that any officer-involved shooting deserves a fair, fact-based review but shouldn’t become an opportunity to score political points.

How we got here. Garces Perez was shot Sept. 20 near the 7000 block of West Anderson Lane during what initial reports described as an attempted traffic stop by an ICE agent, according to a Sept. 22 DA letter. That same day, Garza’s office released a statement asking that APD and the DA’s office be “co-equal partners in the investigation,” and asking the federal government for access to the evidence.

Two days later, the office asked Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin and ICE Director David J. Venturella to halt removal proceedings against Garces Perez. It argued he is a material witness whose testimony would be needed in any future state prosecution. On Sept. 24, Thompson led committee Democrats in a letter to Mullin demanding video, information on the officer and medical records.

The federal side tells a different story. DHS has said Garces Perez, who is from Venezuela, entered the country illegally and had a final order of removal, according to FOX 7. Federal prosecutors have charged him with assaulting and resisting a federal officer, accusing him of hitting an agent with his car’s side mirror while fleeing the stop minutes before the shooting, KUT reported. A federal judge ruled at a hearing that the charge will proceed. His attorney, Kate Lincoln-Goldfinch, has said an unmarked car sideswiped him and that he didn’t know it was ICE.

Body-camera footage is a sore spot. FOX 7 reported that three DHS officials told The Atlantic the officer who fired was a recent hire who wasn’t wearing his body camera. Federal prosecutors did show a judge body-camera video from another officer at the hearing, KUT reported, but that footage remains sealed. The only video released to the public so far is APD’s, from an off-duty detective’s personal dashcam and cellphone and an on-duty officer’s body camera.

What’s next. The letter doesn’t say which federal agencies received the requests or whether any of them responded with a formal refusal. It also doesn’t say how long the state investigation can proceed without the federal evidence. Garza closed by saying his office and APD “will continue to request the cooperation of federal agencies in this investigation.”