Leander ISD police review found 63% of staff rated leadership negatively

A consultant’s review of Leander ISD’s first-year police department, released after the attorney general rejected the district’s bid to keep it private, describes absent leadership, low morale and spotty training.

Share this storyXFacebookLinkedIn

Vista Ridge High School, a Leander ISD campus in Cedar Park, at sunset

An outside review of Leander ISD’s brand-new police department found that most of its staff described leadership as absent or ineffective, morale as poor and training as thin, according to the report’s contents as published this week by KXAN. The district tried to keep the report private. The Texas attorney general said no.

The Docentus Group did the review after two former officers complained to the district in May, and handed it over in mid-July, KXAN reported. About 63% of staff described department leadership negatively, about 52% described morale negatively and nearly 45% described the culture in terms such as dysfunctional or hostile, according to KXAN. At least six employees used the word toxic, the station reported.

What else it found. The review said the department’s written policies met industry standards but that putting them into practice lagged, according to KXAN. Staff told reviewers they lacked regular training in CPR, bleeding control, active-shooter response and time on the gun range. The report recommended the chief meet right away with Cedar Park police, Leander police, Austin police and the Travis County Sheriff’s Office to repair relationships, KXAN reported.

Reviewers also looked at surveillance clips showing two sergeants touching and twirling a non-sworn employee in her chair. They concluded the behavior was not harassment, noting the employee did not find it offensive, but called it unprofessional and recommended a formal review and corrective personnel action, according to KXAN. The district did not tell KXAN whether that happened. The station reported that both sergeants still work for the department.

The report also found that two of the department’s three sergeants hadn’t held a sergeant-level job before, and that few candidates were interviewed for each opening despite a large applicant pool, according to KXAN. Eight employees left during the department’s first year, KVUE reported.

How it got out. In August, the district said in an online statement that the report would be shared only with administrators with “a legitimate need to know” because it contained personnel and sensitive safety information. KXAN filed a public records request in late July. The district asked the attorney general for permission to withhold it, the AG’s office ruled in early October that the district must release it, and the district handed it over about three weeks later, after KXAN said it would air a story about the delay, the station reported.

In a statement to KXAN, the district said it had taken steps to address the findings, that the review was handled at the administrative level without the school board, and that the report reflects the department’s first year, before the district knew about a state investigation.

The state investigation. The Texas Commission on Law Enforcement, which licenses officers, found that 381 of 480 required applicant files hadn’t been opened as part of the department’s background checks, according to the district’s police department Q&A page. The commission recommended a one-year suspension of then-Chief Lucretia “Shā” Rogers’ license. The district says Superintendent Chris Clark placed Rogers on paid leave after receiving that notice on Aug. 7, and the school board voted unanimously Oct. 1 to part ways with her, KXAN reported.

The district’s own timeline raises questions about who knew what. Rogers told Clark in May that the commission had contacted her the previous fall, but described it as involving one former employee’s background check, the Q&A says. Clark says he didn’t learn of the broader investigation until he called the agency July 31. The board “was not aware” of the commission’s concerns prior to “the recent developments,” the district says, because those matters “had not been elevated to trustees.”

What the district says now. In an interview with KVUE published Nov. 11, Clark said he believes students and staff are safe and that the district is working to fix the problems. He said officers now have access to training and equipment they lacked, that the district hired an outside agency to redo background checks on every officer, and that the board and possibly Leander police will have input on a permanent chief, KVUE reported. Jennifer Baskerville, who came to the district after more than 25 years with the Texas Department of Public Safety, has led the department as acting chief since August, according to the district.

Before launching its own department, the district relied on municipal police departments, Clark told KVUE. The Leander ISD board’s meeting schedule is posted on the district website.